How to pay for health insurance if you retire before 65 (and why the subsidy cliff matters)
Investing & Retirement · November 1, 2026 · 16 min read

How to pay for health insurance if you retire before 65 (and why the subsidy cliff matters)

Key takeaways

  • If you retire before 65, you need coverage from the day your employer plan ends until Medicare starts, a gap that can last a few months or 10 years.
  • The main options are a working spouse's plan, retiree coverage, COBRA, and an ACA Marketplace plan. Compare what each one costs to use, including deductibles and out-of-pocket costs, not just the premium.
  • For 2027 coverage, the Marketplace premium tax credit stops above 400% of the federal poverty line: $63,840 for one person and $86,560 for a couple in the lower 48 states.
  • The credit is based on MAGI, not on what you spend. Traditional IRA withdrawals and Roth conversions count toward it. Qualified Roth withdrawals, cash savings, and the cost basis of investments you sell don't.
  • Between 300% and 400% of the poverty line, each extra dollar of MAGI costs about 10 cents of credit. Above 400%, the credit disappears all at once, which is known as the premium tax credit cliff. A Roth conversion in these years can cost far more than your tax bracket suggests.

If you're planning to retire before 65, health insurance is likely already on your mind. It can be the part of the plan that's hardest to pin down.

Other pieces come with a number. Your Social Security statement shows an estimated benefit at each age you could claim. Your 401(k) has a balance. A pension comes with a monthly amount. Health insurance before Medicare doesn't work that way. What you pay depends on which coverage you choose, your age, where you live, and for a Marketplace plan, your income in the year you're covered.

If you've had coverage through work, your employer chose the plan and paid part of the premium. When you retire before 65, that coverage ends with the job unless you continue it through COBRA or your employer offers retiree coverage, and Medicare isn't there yet to take its place. For example, if you're retiring at 64, you may only need to cover a few months. But if you retire at 55, that gap could last 10 years.

The good news is that you have options, and you can line them up before you give notice to your employer.

If you retire before 65, you need health insurance from the day your employer plan ends until Medicare begins. The main options are a spouse's plan, retiree coverage, COBRA, and an ACA Marketplace plan. Compare what each one costs to use, not just the premium, and check how your retirement withdrawals affect what you'd pay for a Marketplace plan.

How long is your bridge?

Before comparing any plans, it helps to figure out how long you actually need coverage. I like to start with three dates:

  1. Your last day of work.
  2. The last day of your employer health coverage, which isn't always the same day.
  3. The month Medicare can begin, which for most people is the month they turn 65.

If you're married, you may need two timelines. For example, one spouse could move to Medicare while the younger spouse still needs coverage for a few more years. If that younger spouse buys a Marketplace plan, the premium tax credit is still based on both spouses' income, and a married couple generally has to file a joint tax return to get it. And if you're planning to claim Social Security at 62, that doesn't move Medicare up. The two programs run on their own schedules.

If you're retiring within the next year

If you're already in your early 60s, your bridge may be short, and you have options that only work for a limited time. For example, COBRA lasts up to 18 months after you leave a job (longer in some specific cases), which could carry someone retiring at 63 and a half all the way to Medicare. A short bridge also means the enrollment deadlines are close, so get written quotes and plan details now rather than after your last day.

If you're in your 50s and planning ahead

If your bridge is longer, COBRA can't cover a five- or ten-year gap on its own, so unless you have retiree coverage, a Marketplace plan or a spouse's plan will likely have to cover most of it. It also means you'll be making this decision every year, not once. Marketplace prices and the rules for premium tax credits can change from year to year, and they did for 2026 when the temporary expanded credits ended. The advantage of planning early is time: you can decide which accounts you'll draw from in those years, and that choice can change what you pay for a Marketplace plan.

The four ways to cover the gap

You'll likely be choosing among four coverage paths. Each one fits a different situation, and each has details to check before you count on it.

A working spouse's employer plan

If your spouse is still working and their employer's plan covers spouses, joining it can be the simplest bridge. Check the enrollment deadline first, because the plan only has to give you 30 days after you lose your own coverage to ask to join. Also find out how much the coverage adds to your spouse's paycheck deductions, and what happens when they retire too, since this bridge ends when their job does.

Retiree coverage from a former employer

Some employers and unions offer health coverage to people who retire before 65. If yours does, find out who qualifies, how much of the premium the employer pays, how long the coverage lasts, and how it works with Medicare later. Being eligible for retiree coverage doesn't stop you from getting a Marketplace premium tax credit, but enrolling in it does. And if you enroll and later drop it on purpose, you won't qualify for a Special Enrollment Period, so you'd have to wait for the next open enrollment to buy a Marketplace plan.

COBRA

COBRA lets you keep the same plan you had at work, with the same doctors and the progress you've already made toward this year's deductible. It's also expensive, because you pay the full premium, including the share your employer used to pay, plus up to a 2% fee. After you leave a job, COBRA lasts up to 18 months, with longer periods in a few special cases. The next section covers when it still makes sense.

An ACA Marketplace plan

The Marketplace (HealthCare.gov, or your state's own exchange) sells individual health plans, and depending on your income, you may qualify for a premium tax credit that lowers the monthly cost. Marketplace plans can't turn you down or charge you more because of a pre-existing condition. The plans vary a lot in their deductibles, out-of-pocket limits, networks, and covered prescriptions, so the details matter as much as the premium.

Other options

Medicaid, military coverage, or benefits through a union or public employer may apply to some households. When you apply for a Marketplace plan, the application also checks whether you qualify for Medicaid.

When COBRA makes sense despite the price

Your first COBRA quote can be a shock. For years, you only saw your share of the premium on your pay stub, and now you're seeing the whole thing, plus a fee. It's easy to look at that number, decide COBRA is simply too expensive, and go straight to the Marketplace.

But a higher premium doesn't always mean a higher total cost. COBRA can come out ahead when:

  • you've already met much of this year's deductible or out-of-pocket maximum, and a new plan may not give you credit for it;
  • you're in the middle of treatment, or you rely on doctors who aren't in the Marketplace plans where you live;
  • your bridge is short enough that COBRA can carry you all the way to Medicare;
  • your income is above the limit for a premium tax credit, so you'd pay full price for a Marketplace plan anyway, and the two should be compared head to head.

If none of those apply to you, a Marketplace plan deserves a close look, and that's where the next sections focus.

Compare what a plan costs to use, not just the premium

When you shop on HealthCare.gov, the first number you'll see is the monthly premium, and the natural move is to sort by it and pick the lowest. If you're healthy and rarely see a doctor, that can feel like the obvious choice.

The premium is what it costs to have the plan. What it costs to use the plan depends on the deductible, the copays and coinsurance, and the out-of-pocket maximum, which is the most you'd pay for covered, in-network care in a year. A plan with a low premium and a high deductible can end up costing more than a pricier plan once you need surgery or a hospital stay.

I like to put two totals next to each plan. The first is what you'd expect to spend in a normal year: twelve months of premiums plus the care you reasonably expect to use. The second is the bad-year cost: twelve months of premiums plus the out-of-pocket maximum. That second number is the most the plan could cost you in a year for covered, in-network care.

Neither total captures a doctor who's out of network or a prescription the plan doesn't cover, so check the network and the drug list for every plan you're seriously considering.

Timing matters too. If you retire in the middle of the year, a new plan may not give you credit for what you've already paid toward your old plan's deductible, so ask the new insurer before you switch. For example, keeping COBRA through December and moving to a Marketplace plan in January could cost more in premiums but save you from paying two deductibles in the same year. Whether that trade makes sense depends on the actual plans you're comparing.

What counts as income for an ACA Marketplace plan in retirement

While you're working, most of your income is your paycheck. In retirement, you have more control over it. Depending on which accounts you draw your spending money from, more or less of that money counts as income, and the Marketplace uses that income to decide how much help you get with the premium.

The premium tax credit is based on a specific measure of income called modified adjusted gross income, or MAGI. It starts with the adjusted gross income on your tax return, then adds back a few items, including tax-exempt interest and any Social Security that wasn't taxed.

In retirement, that means some cash counts and some doesn't. Traditional IRA and 401(k) withdrawals, Roth conversions, pensions, interest, dividends, and realized capital gains all count. A qualified Roth distribution doesn't. When you sell an investment in a taxable account, only the gain counts, not the whole sale. And spending cash you already had in savings doesn't count at all.

For 2027 coverage, the credit stops once household income goes above 400% of the federal poverty guideline. This drop-off is known as the premium tax credit cliff, or the ACA subsidy cliff. In the lower 48 states and Washington, D.C., that's $63,840 for one person and $86,560 for a couple. Alaska and Hawaii use higher figures.

Here's a simplified example of a married couple, both 62, who need $120,000 for the year and have no other income:

Where the cash comes from Cash they spend Counted toward MAGI
Traditional IRA withdrawal $55,000 $55,000
Investments sold from a taxable account ($15,000 of it is gain) $45,000 $15,000
Cash savings $20,000 $0
Total $120,000 $70,000

They spend $120,000, but their MAGI is $70,000, below the $86,560 limit for a couple. At that income, the 2027 rules expect them to pay 10.22% of it, roughly $7,154 a year, toward the benchmark Silver plan, and the tax credit covers the rest of that plan's premium. If the same $120,000 came entirely from their traditional IRA, their MAGI would be $120,000, and they would get no credit at all.

At Styra, my approach is to plan the health insurance decision and the withdrawal plan together, because the account you pull from can change both your tax bill and your premium.

The premium tax credit or a Roth conversion

The years between retiring and Medicare can also be some of the best years for Roth conversions, because your income may be lower than it has been in decades. A Roth conversion moves money from a traditional IRA to a Roth IRA, and you pay income tax on the amount you convert. The problem is that a conversion also counts toward MAGI, so the two goals can conflict.

The credit shrinks in two ways. Below the limit, it shrinks gradually. For a household between 300% and 400% of the poverty line, each extra dollar of MAGI raises your expected share of the premium by about 10 cents, so the credit drops by about 10 cents too. At the limit, it disappears all at once. That's the cliff.

Here's what that looks like for a married couple, both 62, whose MAGI would be $80,000 without a conversion, all from traditional IRA withdrawals. Say their benchmark Silver plan costs $28,700 a year for the two of them, which is about what the average benchmark plan cost two 62-year-olds in Arizona in 2026.

No conversion Convert $6,000 Convert $30,000
MAGI $80,000 $86,000 $110,000
Extra federal tax (12% bracket) none $720 $3,600
Premium tax credit $20,524 $19,911 $0
Total cost of the conversion none $1,333 $24,124
Effective rate on the amount converted none about 22% about 80%

Below the limit, every dollar they convert costs 12% in federal tax plus about 10% in lost credit, because their expected share of the premium rises with their income. That works out to about 22%, before state taxes. Once the conversion crosses the limit, the cost jumps. Converting $30,000 costs $3,600 in tax plus the entire $20,524 credit, which is about 80% of the amount converted.

How big the cliff is depends on where you live. The credit covers the difference between your expected share and the local benchmark premium, so where premiums run higher, the credit is bigger, and so is what you'd lose by crossing the limit. In 2026, Arizona's average benchmark premium was lower than in 38 of the 50 states and Washington, D.C., so in most of the country the cliff would be larger than this example shows.

(Tax figures use 2026 federal brackets, the latest published, and ignore state taxes. The premium is Arizona's 2026 average; 2027 premiums are rising.)

On the other hand, a conversion can lower the taxes you pay for the rest of your life. Money you convert now won't be part of your required minimum distributions later, and it can grow and come out tax-free. If you convert while you're in a lower tax bracket than you expect to be in later, the long-term savings can be large, sometimes larger than the credit you gave up.

There isn't one right answer here, and with a decision like this, you may not know whether you made the right call for decades. Whether a conversion pays off depends on things nobody knows yet: future tax rates, how your investments do, how long you live, and who inherits what's left. The lost credit is different. You can see exactly what it costs on this year's numbers. In a sense, the credit is the devil you know.

For me, it comes down to two things. The first is the numbers: what the credit is actually worth for your household, and what a conversion is likely to save over your lifetime. The second is how you feel about the trade. Some people are comfortable giving up a certain amount today for a likely payoff later, and some would rather keep the credit they know they'll get. Both are reasonable positions.

There are also ways to soften the trade-off, like doing larger conversions in some years and staying under the limit in others, but whether that works depends on your numbers.

Know your enrollment deadlines

When your job-based coverage ends, several deadlines start at the same time, and if you miss one, you can lose that option. These are the federal rules, so check your plan's notices for the exact dates that apply to you.

  • If you want a Marketplace plan, you can sign up from 60 days before to 60 days after your coverage ends. This is called a Special Enrollment Period.
  • If you want to join a spouse's employer plan, the plan has to give you at least 30 days after you lose your own coverage to ask. Don't count on having more time than that.
  • If you're considering COBRA, you have at least 60 days to elect it, and once you elect it and pay, your coverage goes back to the day your old coverage ended.

There's one timing trap to watch for. If you start COBRA and then drop it on purpose after your Marketplace window has closed, that doesn't qualify you for a new Special Enrollment Period. Running out of COBRA at the end of its 18 months does.

If your timing lines up with open enrollment, you have another window. For 2027 coverage on HealthCare.gov, open enrollment runs from November 1, 2026, through January 15, 2027. If you sign up by December 15, your coverage starts January 1. States that run their own Marketplace can set different dates. Arizona uses HealthCare.gov, and the Arizona Department of Insurance and Financial Institutions has a page with this year's dates and shopping tips.

Finally, if you're getting close to 65, COBRA doesn't give you extra time to sign up for Medicare Part B. Plan for Medicare to start when you turn 65 rather than assuming COBRA lets you wait.

Before you give notice

Whichever bridge you're building, it helps to get it down to one page before your last day. What goes on that page depends on how far out you are.

If you're retiring within the next year

  1. Write down the exact date your current coverage ends and the month Medicare can start for each of you.
  2. Get the written COBRA premium from HR, along with the details of any retiree coverage or spouse's plan.
  3. Get Marketplace quotes using the income you expect in the year you'll be covered, not last year's salary.
  4. Check that your doctors and prescriptions are covered by each plan you're considering.
  5. Add up the normal-year cost and the bad-year cost for each one.

If you're in your 50s and planning ahead

  1. Map out how many years each of you will need coverage before Medicare.
  2. Sketch which accounts you'll draw from in each of those years, and what your MAGI would be.
  3. Decide how you'll weigh the premium tax credit against Roth conversions, using your household's numbers.
  4. Revisit the plan every fall before open enrollment, since premiums and the credit rules can change from year to year.

Health insurance before 65 is a real cost, and it's tied to your tax plan in ways that are easy to miss. For the cash-flow side of that plan, see How to turn your retirement savings into a monthly paycheck. For more on the tax decision that can reduce your Marketplace credit, see The Roth conversion window between retiring and RMDs.

Frequently asked questions

Do IRA withdrawals count as income for the premium tax credit? Yes. Traditional IRA and 401(k) withdrawals count toward the MAGI the Marketplace uses, and so do Roth conversions. Qualified withdrawals from a Roth IRA don't.

Is COBRA or a Marketplace plan better? It depends on your situation. COBRA can come out ahead if you've already met much of this year's deductible, you're in the middle of treatment, or Medicare is less than 18 months away. A Marketplace plan can cost far less if you qualify for a premium tax credit, so compare the two using the full-year cost, not just the premium.

How much does health insurance cost if I retire at 62? It depends on where you live, the plan you choose, and your income. In 2026, the average benchmark Silver plan for a 62-year-old in Arizona cost about $1,200 a month before any tax credit, and a couple pays that for each person. If your MAGI is below 400% of the poverty line, a premium tax credit can bring that down a lot.

Can I use my HSA to pay health insurance premiums before Medicare? Only for certain kinds of coverage. HSA money can pay COBRA premiums, and it can pay health coverage premiums while you're receiving unemployment benefits, but it can't pay regular Marketplace premiums. You can still use it for deductibles, copays, and other qualified medical expenses. And starting in 2026, every Bronze and catastrophic Marketplace plan counts as HSA-eligible, according to the IRS, so you can keep contributing to an HSA in retirement without a paycheck.

Sources

This post is general information, not personalized advice. Talk to a fee-only fiduciary about your specific situation.

Share this post
← All posts

Get the next one by email

One email a month on retirement and tax planning, written for people working towards, transitioning to, and thriving in retirement.

No pitches. Unsubscribe anytime.

Ready to get your plan in place?

Forty-five minutes with Jacob to talk through your questions and see whether the relationship fits. Complimentary, with no pressure and no pitch.

See if we're a fit