How to choose which retirement account to withdraw from first (and why the answer can change every year)
Key takeaways
- The usual withdrawal order (taxable brokerage account first, then traditional IRA or 401(k), then Roth) is a reasonable starting point, but the best order can change when you reach Medicare, start Social Security, and begin required minimum distributions.
- Before Medicare, living on a brokerage account can keep taxable income low. In a hypothetical 2026 example, a married couple at 62 sells $100,000 of investments with a $40,000 gain and owes $0 in federal income tax.
- Between Medicare and Social Security, traditional IRA withdrawals can be partly covered by deductions. In a hypothetical 2026 example, a married couple at 66 withdraws $120,000 and pays about 6.8% in federal income tax, because $47,500 of the withdrawal is offset by deductions.
- Once Social Security begins, one extra dollar from a traditional IRA can add up to $1.85 of taxable income, which makes Roth withdrawals and qualified charitable distributions more useful.
- The order with the lowest lifetime tax and the order that leaves your heirs the most can be different, so the right choice depends on your goals and is worth revisiting every year.
For most of your career, your financial questions likely revolved around how much to save and which account to save it in. Over the years, you may have built up a 401(k) or traditional IRA from pre-tax contributions, and maybe contributed to a Roth IRA, or a brokerage account when you had extra savings.
When you retire and the paychecks stop, the questions you ask change significantly. Now you're distributing money from the accounts to support your spending, and most of these accounts are taxed differently when the money comes out. A $10,000 withdrawal can add the full $10,000 to your taxable income, only part of it, or nothing at all, depending on which account it came from. In some cases, it can even add more than $10,000, because the extra income can make more of your Social Security taxable or shrink a deduction you were counting on.
There's a reasonable starting point you may have heard before: spend the taxable account first, then the traditional accounts, and save the Roth for last. It is a good answer, it just isn't the whole answer, because the account that makes the most sense to draw from can change as you move through retirement. As you read more of what I write, you'll see a recurring theme of "it depends" and "maybe". It's just really hard to give definitive answers to a lot of these questions without knowing your specific facts, circumstances, and financial goals.
So which account should you withdraw from first? It partly depends on which stage of retirement you're in. Before Medicare, drawing from your brokerage account first can keep your income low for health insurance subsidies. Between Medicare and Social Security, your traditional IRA might be the better option. After that, Social Security and required withdrawals can take over, and maybe you'll plan to use your Roth to fill the gaps.
Before Medicare, your brokerage account often goes first
If you retire before 65, a taxable brokerage account can often be the best place to start. When you sell an investment there, the part that was your original investment (your cost basis) comes back tax-free, and only the appreciation (your gain) counts as income. For 2026, a married couple filing jointly pays 0% on long-term gains as long as their taxable income stays under $98,900, according to the IRS.
Low income also helps if you buy health insurance through the Marketplace. The premium tax credit, the subsidy that lowers your premium, gets smaller as your income rises, and for 2026 a two-person household loses it entirely above $84,600. I cover this in how to pay for health insurance if you retire before 65. Cody Garrett and Sean Mullaney make a good case for spending brokerage money first in their book Tax Planning To and Through Early Retirement.
Here's an example. Let's say a married couple, both 62, has no pension and hasn't claimed Social Security. They sell $100,000 from their brokerage account to cover the year, and $40,000 of that sale is long-term gain.
| Amount | |
|---|---|
| Long-term capital gain | $40,000 |
| Standard deduction (2026) | ($32,200) |
| Taxable income | $7,800 |
| Federal income tax | $0 |
Their $7,800 of taxable income is all long-term gain under the $98,900 line, so it's taxed at 0%. They could also convert $32,200 from their traditional IRA to a Roth and still owe $0, because the standard deduction would cover it. The cost is a smaller health insurance credit, since their income for the credit rises from $40,000 to $72,200. The credit is based on your income before the standard deduction, so all $32,200 of the conversion counts against it.
This is a clear-cut example that works if the brokerage account fully supports the couple's lifestyle until they reach 65. If the balance isn't enough to bridge your lifestyle until you reach Medicare age, you could blend IRA and brokerage withdrawals each year to keep your income moderate the whole way. Also keep in mind that your Medicare premiums at 65 are based on your income at 63.
Between Medicare and Social Security, your IRA can take over
Once you're on Medicare, keeping your income low for the health insurance credit is no longer a concern. If you're also delaying Social Security, and required withdrawals haven't started yet, your income in these years can be lower than at any other point in retirement. That makes it a good time to start drawing down the traditional IRA.
Part of each IRA withdrawal can come out tax-free, because your deductions cover it. At 65, the standard deduction gets an extra $1,650 per person for a married couple in 2026. On top of that, a new senior deduction of $6,000 per person applies from 2025 through 2028. It begins to phase out once a married couple's income passes $150,000 and is completely gone at $250,000.
Here's another example. Let's say a married couple, both 66, is delaying Social Security and takes $120,000 from their traditional IRA for the year.
| Amount | |
|---|---|
| Traditional IRA withdrawal | $120,000 |
| Standard deduction (2026) | ($32,200) |
| Additional deduction for age 65 and older | ($3,300) |
| Senior deduction | ($12,000) |
| Taxable income | $72,500 |
| Federal income tax | $8,204 |
About $47,500 of their withdrawal is never taxed, and they pay about 6.8% on the full $120,000. Every dollar they take out now is also a dollar that won't be part of a required withdrawal later.
If you still have brokerage money, the other option is to keep living on it and convert IRA money to a Roth during these years. How much you convert is widely debated. Some argue to keep conversions within the deductions or the 12% bracket. Others convert more, sometimes into the 22% or 24% bracket, when the IRA is large enough that future required withdrawals, or a surviving spouse filing single, could face higher rates. And then there are considerations around Medicare premiums. For 2026, the Medicare premium surcharge, known as IRMAA, starts once a married couple's income passes $218,000, so a large conversion can raise your premiums two years later. All that to say, once again, "it depends".
Once Social Security and required withdrawals start, things settle down a bit
Once Social Security starts, you have a new income floor every year, and your IRA withdrawals stack on top of it. Depending on your other income, up to 85% of your Social Security benefit can become taxable. In the income range where more of your benefit is becoming taxable, a single dollar distributed from your IRA can add as much as $1.85 to your taxable income: the dollar itself, plus 85 cents of Social Security that wasn't taxed before.
At some point, your required minimum distributions (RMDs) begin. They start at 73 if you were born from 1951 through 1959, and at 75 if you were born in 1960 or later. Your RMD has to come out before anything else each year, and it can't be converted to a Roth.
So now you've got Social Security covering part (or potentially all) of your living expenses, and you have RMDs from your traditional IRA. There are some ways to help keep your taxable income lower even with these income sources:
- Charitable giving: Starting at 70.5, a qualified charitable distribution (QCD) sends money straight from your IRA to a charity. It counts toward your RMD but is not part of your taxable income, which can also keep more of your Social Security untaxed. The limit is $111,000 per person for 2026.
- Your Roth IRA: This can almost act as a plug to fill the gaps between your "income floor" (Social Security and RMDs) and what you need to live. If one more IRA dollar would push you into a higher tax bracket or a Medicare surcharge tier, you can pull that money tax-free from a Roth instead.
Roth conversions are harder to justify at this stage. Every dollar you convert is taxed on top of your RMD and Social Security income, and can make more of your Social Security taxable too. There is an argument to be made if your heirs are likely to pay a higher rate on the money you plan to leave them than you would.
If your RMD is more than you spend, you can reinvest what's left in your brokerage account.
The lowest-tax order may not always be the best one
Everything so far has been about paying the least tax over your lifetime. That's an important goal, but it isn't the only one. The order you choose also changes what your kids inherit and what the surviving spouse is left to manage.
Each account passes to your heirs differently:
| Account | What your heirs generally owe |
|---|---|
| Brokerage account | Little or nothing on past growth, because the cost basis gets stepped up to the value at the date of death |
| Traditional IRA | Every dollar is subject to income tax, and most heirs other than a spouse must empty it within 10 years |
| Roth IRA | Generally nothing, though most heirs other than a spouse must still empty it within 10 years |
So spending the brokerage account first, which often saves you the most tax, can leave your kids a pre-tax IRA that costs them the most. If your children inherit during their peak earning years, those IRA withdrawals are taxed as income on top of their salaries.
The surviving spouse can face a similar situation. After the first spouse dies, the survivor generally files as single, which means that the tax brackets shrink, but the IRA is the same size. That's one reason some couples convert more while they're both alive.
There's the answer that's "correct" on paper, and there's the answer that lets you sleep at night. If you're comfortable paying more tax during your lifetime so your kids receive more, that's a perfectly reasonable choice. At Styra, my job is to make sure it's a choice you make on purpose. The way I'd lay it out is two numbers side by side for each option: the total taxes you'd pay over your lifetime, and what's left for your heirs after tax.
Even then, there's no way to know for decades whether you picked the best order. Tax law, the markets, and your own life will all change along the way. What you can do is make the best decision with the information you have today, and then look at it again each year.
This is an ongoing decision
Your withdrawal order isn't something you decide once at retirement. It works best as a plan you set at the start of each year and look at again before the next year.
At the start of the year, estimate the income you already know is coming: Social Security, any pension, your RMD, and the interest and dividends your accounts pay out. Then you can pick a target, an income level you want to land near or stay under. Depending on your stage of retirement, that might be the top of a tax bracket (12%, 22%, etc.), the 0% capital gains line, the health insurance credit cliff, or a Medicare surcharge tier. Once you decide how much income you want, that can help guide your decision on which accounts fund the year.
In the fall, you can double check the actual numbers. If you own mutual funds in a brokerage account, any capital gain distributions they pay count as income for the year, so that's something to account for. Maybe you had a large unexpected expense and need to withdraw more than you initially expected to. If you're under your target, there may be room for a Roth conversion or a larger IRA withdrawal. If you're over it, your last withdrawals of the year can come from the Roth.
If you haven't retired yet, there are two questions you can ask yourself right now. How many years of spending can your brokerage account cover? And how many years will you have between your last paycheck and Medicare? If your brokerage account can carry you all the way to Medicare, your first years may look like the example couple at 62 above. If it can't, blending IRA and brokerage withdrawals from the start may fit better.
For the bigger picture, see retirement planning once you're already retired. For turning these withdrawals into a steady deposit in your checking account, see how to turn your retirement savings into a monthly paycheck.
Frequently asked questions
Is a Roth conversion part of my withdrawal order?
It's a separate decision, but it uses the same tax room. A traditional IRA withdrawal and a Roth conversion both add to your taxable income, so every dollar you convert takes up space you could have used for a withdrawal at the same rate. I cover the timing in the Roth conversion window between retiring and RMDs.
Should I spend my Roth or save it for my kids?
It depends on whose taxes you're trying to lower. Your heirs generally owe no income tax on an inherited Roth, which is one reason some people save it for last. Using some of it during your lifetime, though, can keep you out of a higher bracket or a Medicare surcharge tier. Which matters more depends on your goals for the money.
What if almost all my savings are in pre-tax accounts?
Then your IRA or 401(k) funds most of your retirement from the start, and the question becomes how much to take each year rather than which account to use. Your deductions can still cover part of each withdrawal. If you retire before 59.5, withdrawals generally carry a 10% additional tax unless an exception applies, so the timing of your retirement matters too.
When is the deadline for a Roth conversion?
A conversion counts for the tax year it's completed in, so the deadline for a given year is December 31. Once it's done, it can't be undone, which is why the amount is easier to size once you have a good estimate of that year's income.
Which account should I draw from if the market drops?
Some retirees keep part of their portfolio in cash or bonds so they can cover spending without selling stocks after a drop. Whether that fits your situation depends on your spending, your other income, and how large a decline you can live with. I walk through the trade-offs in what happens if the market drops right after I retire.
Sources
- IRS, Revenue Procedure 2025-32 (2026 tax brackets, standard deduction, and capital gains rates)
- IRS, One Big Beautiful Bill Act tax deductions for working Americans and seniors
- IRS, Schedule 1-A (Form 1040)
- IRS, Questions and answers on the premium tax credit
- HealthCare.gov, Federal poverty level
- Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services, 2026 Medicare Parts A and B premiums and deductibles
- IRS, Publication 915, Social Security and equivalent railroad retirement benefits
- IRS, Publication 590-B, Distributions from individual retirement arrangements
- IRS, Publication 590-A, Contributions to individual retirement arrangements
- IRS, Notice 2025-67 (2026 qualified charitable distribution limit)
- IRS, Publication 551, Basis of assets
- Cody Garrett and Sean Mullaney, Tax Planning To and Through Early Retirement
This post is general information, not personalized advice. Talk to a fee-only fiduciary about your specific situation.